Kim
Imagine paying for your morning coffee with what seems like a regular Susan B. Anthony dollar, only to discover weeks later that the same coin fetched an astonishing $890,000 at auction.
That’s exactly what happened to one lucky buyer at an Ohio diner—proof that sometimes a small act can lead to a life-changing discovery.
A Simple Coffee Purchase with a Stunning Twist
A woman in rural Ohio stopped at the Cozy Corner Diner and paid her $9.50 bill, including a Susan B. Anthony dollar in change.
The cashier thought nothing of it—it looked just like any other coin. No one suspected that this modest piece of metal would later make headlines in the numismatic world.
The Discovery That Shocked Collectors
Weeks later, a coin expert examined the coin and noticed it wasn’t an ordinary Susan B. Anthony dollar—it was in near-perfect Mint State condition, and showed rare characteristics unseen in circulation.
When it hit the auction block, it shattered records, selling for an incredible $890,000—far beyond the typical $20,000 ceiling even for valuable variants.
What Makes This Coin So Valuable?
Several key factors contributed to its staggering value:
1. Immaculate Condition
Graded on the Mint State (MS) scale, especially MS67 or higher, a coin is considered flawless. This particular example was nearly perfect—an exceptional find for a coin punched and circulated.
2. Rare Variety Traits
Some Susan B. Anthony dollars were minting anomalies, like the 1979‑P “Wide Rim”, which appeal to collectors. This coin exhibited such rare characteristics, boosting its worth.
3. Provenance and Story
Coins with memorable origins hold additional value. This one started as payment for a cup of coffee—then traveled to a record-breaking auction. Collectors pay premiums for provenance-rich pieces.
4. Rising Interest in Women’s History Coins
As the first U.S. coin to feature a real woman, interest in Susan B. Anthony dollars has grown. This coin captured that momentum, skyrocketing its appeal.
Meet the Susan B. Anthony Dollar
- Minted: 1979–1981, 1999
- Designer: Frank Gasparro
- Composition: Copper-nickel clad (75% copper, 25% nickel)
- Size & Weight: 26.5 mm diameter, 8.1 g
- Edge: Reeded
- Face: Portrait of Susan B. Anthony
- Reverse: Eagle design from Apollo 11
Though intended to circulate like a dollar coin, public confusion with quarters led to limited use. Many ended up locked away—prime condition for future discoveries.
Normal vs. Exotic Market Values
| Coin Type | Typical Value |
|---|---|
| Circulated basic SBA dollar | $1–$10 |
| Uncirculated MS65‑MS66 SBA dollar | $250–$1,900 |
| Rare varieties/proof coins | Up to ~$21,600 |
| The coffee‑diner “stun coin” | $890,000 at auction! |
This one-of-a-kind piece shattered expectations and cemented its place in numismatic lore.
Why the Story-Making Difference?
What really set this coin apart was its origin story. A coin used for coffee, later authenticated and sold for nearly a million dollars? That’s the kind of narrative coin collectors love. Provenance, rarity, and condition all aligned—making this more than just currency—it became a legend.
Tips for Treasure Hunters
- Check every Susan B. Anthony dollar in your change—especially those with unusual rims or mintmarks.
- Condition matters: coins with high Mint State grades are exponentially more valuable.
- Get rare variants authenticated by professionals. Small differences can translate to large sums.
- Remember provenance: if your coin has a backstory, document it—provenance can raise value by 10–30%.
The story of the Susan B. Anthony dollar used to pay for coffee—and later selling for $890,000—is a thrilling reminder that true treasures can lie in unsuspecting places. Beyond value, it shows the intersection of history, condition, rarity, and provenance.
So next time you pay for your latte, think twice before passing along that seemingly ordinary dollar—you might be part of the next sensational discovery.
FAQs
What makes a Susan B. Anthony dollar so valuable?
High condition, rare minting errors, and a strong provenance—like its part in everyday life—can skyrocket a coin’s worth.
Should I get my Susan B. Anthony dollars professionally graded?
Absolutely. Grading by a reputable service confirms condition and greatly enhances a coin’s market value.
How can I research or sell a rare coin?
Reach out to certified dealers or auction houses specializing in coins. They can guide selling processes and verify authenticity.